Unsure if you need orthotics? Schedule your free online evaluation.

Can Insoles Make Shoes Smaller?

Have you ever found the ideal pair of shoes, only to realize they’re slightly too large? Before you consider returning them, you might want to explore the possibility of using insoles to adjust the fit. Insoles are not just for foot support or comfort; they can also serve as an effective means to fill extra space inside shoes that are a tad too big. However, whether or not insoles can make shoes smaller depends on several factors, which this article will explore in-depth.

Table of Contents

Introduction to Insoles

Insoles are inserts placed inside footwear for various reasons, including comfort enhancement, foot alignment correction, and size adjustment. These inserts can be made from a wide array of materials like foam, gel, leather, or a combination of these. The thickness and density of the insole material directly influence the amount of space it occupies within the shoe, which can potentially lead to a smaller shoe fit.

Impact of Insoles on Shoe Size

Insoles can indeed affect the internal dimensions of your shoes. When you place an insole inside a shoe, it fills up some of the excess room. This is particularly useful for those who find themselves in between shoe sizes or have narrow feet. The right insole can fill up that half-size space, making the shoes fit closer to your foot’s actual size. This effect, however, has its limits. Insoles are great for slight adjustments but may not be sufficient for downsizing shoes by more than one shoe size.

Choosing the Right Insoles for Size Reduction

When selecting insoles to make your shoes fit smaller, you need to consider more than just size. The material, design, and specific features of the insole are crucial:

  • Material: Softer materials like foam can provide a cushioning effect and are good for slight adjustments. For more significant size reduction, look for denser materials like leather or firm synthetic blends.
  • Design: Some insoles are full-length, spanning the entire bottom of the shoe, while others are three-quarter length or even just heel inserts. Full-length insoles are more likely to affect overall shoe size.
  • Footbed type: Contoured footbeds with arch support might take up more space and are an option if you also require additional foot support.
  • Volume: Insoles come in different volumes—high, medium, and low. High-volume insoles take up the most space and can alter shoe size the most.

As you can see, the selection process for insoles is quite intricate and requires careful consideration to ensure not only a better fit but also continued comfort and foot health.

Different Types of Insoles

Understanding the various types of insoles available is crucial to making the right choice for your needs:

  • Comfort insoles: Often made of gel or soft foam, these insoles are designed primarily for shock absorption and are less about size reduction. However, they can slightly tighten a fit due to their cushioning.
  • Support insoles: Firmer than comfort insoles, they are usually crafted to provide stability and support to the arch. Because of their structure, they can make a shoe feel somewhat smaller.
  • Orthotic insoles: These are often custom-made and can be quite thick to correct foot posture. They are an excellent choice if the shoe is larger and if you require foot correction.
  • Sport insoles: These are designed with activities in mind and can be thicker to absorb impact, potentially making the shoe fit more snugly.

The key to selecting the right type of insole is to understand your own needs. If size reduction is your only goal, then opting for a high-volume support or orthotic insole may be beneficial. However, if comfort is a priority, you might need to compromise slightly on the size adjustment for the added cushioning comfort insoles provide.

Fit Adjustment Techniques

In addition to insoles, there are other strategies you can use to improve the fit of a shoe aside from insoles:

  • Heel liners: These sticky pads can be affixed to the inside of the heel to prevent your foot from slipping out.
  • Tongue pads: If there’s too much space on the top of your foot, tongue pads can fill this gap and offer a tighter fit.
  • Shoe stuffing: For occasional wear, temporary stuffing in the toe area can make the shoe fit more snugly.
  • Shoe lacing techniques: Certain lacing methods can secure the foot better and reduce slippage inside the shoe.

These methods can be particularly helpful if you’re dealing with shoes that are too large by more than a small margin. Experimenting with these different techniques in combination with insoles can yield the best results for achieving a snugger, more secure fit.

Limitations and Considerations

There are inherent limitations to using insoles for making shoes smaller. For instance, a very thick insole might cause the shoe to fit too tightly, resulting in discomfort or restricted blood flow. Additionally, altering the inside of the shoe with insoles can change the dynamics of how your foot interacts with the shoe. It can affect your gait and potentially lead to alignment issues if not properly addressed.

It’s also worth noting that not every shoe will accommodate an insole without affecting its look or functionality. Dress shoes, ballet flats, or other low-profile shoes might not have the necessary space to fit an insole without altering the shoe’s appearance or making it uncomfortable to wear.

When using insoles, it’s essential to consider the shoe’s construction and design. Shoes with removable footbeds are usually the best candidates for insole replacement since they are designed to allow for extra space. In contrast, shoes with non-removable footbeds might not offer the same flexibility and could lead to a cramped fit when adding an insole.

When to Seek Professional Assistance

If after trying insoles and other methods you’re still struggling with shoe fit, it might be time to seek professional advice. A podiatrist can offer custom orthotic insoles that are designed to fit your feet precisely, offering a combination of size reduction and foot health benefits. For more permanent structural changes, a skilled cobbler or shoe repair specialist can alter your shoes to decrease their size effectively.

Moreover, it’s advisable to get a professional fitting before making any significant changes to your footwear. Trained professionals can identify the exact fit issues and suggest the most effective, individualized solutions. They can also ensure that any adjustments made will not compromise the shoe’s structure or your comfort in the long run.


Insoles can be a practical solution for making shoes fit smaller, but they are not a one-size-fits-all answer. The extent to which insoles can adjust the size of your shoes depends on the degree of size discrepancy, the type of insoles used, and the specific characteristics of the shoes in question. When contemplating insoles as a solution for oversized shoes, it’s important to weigh the benefits against the potential downsides, such as discomfort or changes to your walking pattern.

For minor adjustments, insoles combined with other fitting techniques can offer a quick fix. However, when it comes to more significant sizing issues or specific foot health concerns, professional input becomes invaluable. Remember, the ultimate goal is to achieve a balance between a better fit and optimal foot health. Whether through insoles or professional shoe modifications, ensuring a proper shoe fit is crucial for both comfort and foot function.